Review workflow
Review a change on two independent axes:
- Standards: does the change follow the repository's documented standards, including reviewer standards?
- Spec: does the change implement the originating ticket or specification without scope creep?
Steps
- Pin the fixed point and read the diff from it, for example
git diff <fixed-point>...HEAD. - Read the originating issue and its acceptance criteria.
- Read the contribution guide and the reviewer standards. Run
npm run verifyand the relevant live checks rather than trusting their description. - Report Standards and Spec findings separately. Cite the standard section or the ticket line for each finding.
- Record verification evidence and any remaining manual or unexecuted checks.
Mechanical rules are enforced by npm run verify, the live checks, and CI. Do not re-report them as judgement findings. The reviewer standards cover the judgement calls that automation cannot make.